Returns are a fact in eCommerce, but the way a business handles them can either build trust or drive customers straight into the arms of a competitor. A poorly designed return can also harm your reputation and lead to lost repeat business. 

Making Your Return Policy Hard to Find or Understand 

One of the biggest mistakes online retailers make is hiding their return policy or making it overly complicated. Customers expect transparency, and when they have to dig through dense legal text or multiple pages to figure out how to return an item, it creates frustration before they’ve even made a purchase. 

Studies show that over 60% of shoppers check the return policy before making a purchase, and nearly three-quarters say the ease of returns directly influences whether they’ll shop with a retailer again. When the policy is hard to find or confusing, it can create a sense of risk that deters people from completing a purchase.  

A simple, clear, and easily accessible return policy not only reassures buyers but also builds confidence in your brand. 

Offering a Return Window That’s Too Short 

Another common mistake is setting a return window that is too restrictive. A seven-day return window might seem like a good way to reduce returns, but it can leave customers feeling rushed. Many consumers expect at least two to four weeks to make a return decision, and a short window can lead to abandoned purchases.  

In fact, a survey found that more than 60% of shoppers are less likely to buy if the return window feels too limited. Offering a reasonable timeframe shows customers that you value their satisfaction and trust them to make decisions on their own schedule, which in turn encourages repeat purchases. 

Making the Return Process Complicated 

Even if the return policy is clear and the window is generous, a convoluted return process can undo all of that. If customers have to print forms, schedule pickups, or navigate confusing procedures, they may abandon the return or feel frustrated enough to leave negative reviews. 90% of shoppers are likely to return to a retailer if the return process is easy, while a complicated process can erode loyalty and trust. Simplifying returns through an easy self-service system, clear instructions, and convenient drop-off or mail-in options can turn a potentially negative experience into a positive interaction with your brand. 

Turning Returns into a Competitive Advantage 

A customer-friendly return policy is an opportunity to build trust and create a positive brand impression. Avoiding these common mistakes and making the process simple, transparent, and fair can have a measurable impact on customer loyalty.  

SalesWarp can help streamline returns management by connecting marketplaces, tracking returns, and automating workflows, making it easier to offer a hassle-free experience for your customers. 

Want to learn more? Speak to an Expert!